Natural and uncontrollable influences need to be considered in your design.
In permaculture, the term sector refers to any natural or uncontrolled influence that moves through your design site. And through sector analysis, you can anticipate and enact design decisions that will mediate, mitigate, and improve how those uncontrolled influences affect your site.
Sectors could be wind, water, weather…they can be economic, social, biological, or any combination of the above. Every sector has needs, resources, yields, wastes, and relationships that influence the whole system.
A work-zone is a sector, with uses, yields, and wastes. A children’s play area is a sector, and has needs and resources associated with it. The cold, moldy side of the basement is a sector (AND a microclimate–we’ll get to that next week), with opportunities intrinsic (mushrooms, anyone?)“Invisible structures” are mostly sectors as well, and so is your “inner landscape.”
Every site, no matter where you are, has a complex labyrinth of sectors to consider when making choices about your design. Sector analysis will help you identify microclimates and discover opportunities that weren’t obvious at first glance. The more you know, the better decisions you can make.
Permaculture sector mapping: identifying risks and designing solutions
The potential for disaster happens when systems can not handle extremes or cumulative stress. One week of limited spending may be a challenge, but a medical bill on top of long-term debt and structural poverty may force a family into homelessness. Water is essential for life, but the extremes of either drought or flood-causing torrential rain can cause havoc in both natural and human systems.
Designing land, the built environment, lifestyles, livelihoods and organisations to deal with extremes as well as everyday conditions is essential for resilience. There are many ways in which permaculture design and practice supports resilience, but in order to do that it is important to understand what extremes are most likely to have an impact. This is why careful observation and sector analysis is so important for a successful project.
Sector analysis is a critical tool for visually representing observations about the “sectors” or external forces and elements that move through or otherwise influence your project. The sectors you record can be related to effects on the site caused by climate, ecology, geology, topography and society. For example sun paths, wind and rain patterns, invasive plants, wildlife, pollution, neighbours, areas of high fire threat, views and noise could all be recorded on your sector analysis layer.
Sectors are often represented as labelled wedges, arcs or arrows representing the origin and direction of the element. However, rocky areas, contaminated soil, boggy land, or areas of flood risk are better represented as location specific patches over your base map. Some uncontrollable issues such as geological instability or limiting factors such as legal restrictions are harder to represent visually and are best recorded in writing.
Sector analysis often represents the origin of different forces through arcs.
Part of developing Designer’s Mind is about making observations free of bias. The forces recorded on a sector analysis are neutral and can be both beneficial or harmful.
For example, knowing that dry summer winds come from the east helps identify the best place to locate a laundry line or to hang produce for drying. At the same time, that drying wind will quickly evaporate water from soil as well as dams or ponds. This information guides the placement of windbreak plantings or hedges on the eastern side to moderate the impact of the wind and reduce evaporation.
Used together with tools such as zone analysis, sector analysis helps guide the placement of components so that they make best use of or mitigate the risks of that sector. Sector analysis influences which zones are placed where, but at the same time, zones influence the strategies used to respond to external forces. In outer zones such as 3 or 4, lower cost, less energy intensive solutions such as windbreak plantings are used to slow the wind. Closer to the home more intensive solutions such as walls or use of grey water might be used to protect water-demanding plants, animals and people from a drying wind.
You should make a sector analysis for your overarching project, and you should also make analyses for sub-designs such as high intensity vegetable beds that include smaller scale microclimate influences like the impact of trees casting shade.
Working on sector analysis is a great way to review and incorporate the ideas from everything else you’ve been seeing and learning. Your sector analysis should help you identify the risks, or major extremes that will threaten the longevity of your design projects whether they be fire, flood, drought or legal challenges.
Sector mapping will generally take way more than one sitting to finish, and sectors will change, so you have to keep mapping! As such, it’s a thing to keep in mind, and in progress, as you move through the weeks and months toward your whole-system design.
Here are some steps to get you started:
- Make a bunch of extra copies of the base map you created last week. Or, if working digitally, create a dozen or so empty layers.
- Make a list of possible sectors influencing your site, and then label each layer; one for each sector.
- Begin mapping your sectors, laying them over your basemap, and looking for intersections, limitation, opportunities, and inspirations therein.
And yes, as mentioned above, don’t stop with just mapping the sun/wind/water sectors! Go deeper, into each fractal layer of the design, and look for repeated patterns. Recognize that sectors may have subtle effects in small areas, creating “microclimates,” and that those microclimates are bursting with opportunity!
Relevant Links and Resources
In the video above, one of the things Pippa talks about is apartment-scale sector analysis.
By contrast, here’s a discussion of farm scale sector analysis, from the folks at Grass-fed Homestead
This is a detailed, excellent video about how to make a permaculture sector analysis, from Steve Gabriel of Wellspring Permaculture. He is using Illustrator, which is not free and fairly complicated, but you can for sure translate the knowledge here to hand-drawn maps and/or a free tool like Autodesk Sketchbook.